The Institutions Bought CarMax In Q3, Now It's Cheaper 

CarMax (NASDAQ: KMX) had a rough quarter but the weakness is to be expected in a world where prices are rising everywhere you look and particularly fast in the used car industry. The company’s Q2 results were weaker than expected but also reveal the company’s underlying strength and position within the used car market. While near-term headwinds are pressuring the business, the business continues to expand and gain market share which will be a double-boost for revenue and earnings when the industry stabilizes. 

The Sell-Side Is Holding And Buying CarMax 

The institutions were buying the stock heavily going into the report and may step up their buying now that prices are at a 30-month low. The institutions have been net buyers for the last 5 quarters, in fact, and ramped their purchases to multi-year highs in Q2 and Q3 of this year. This has their total holdings up to 96.1% and growing which is a noteworthy fact in light of the 1.65% insider holdings and the 8.5% short interest. All it will take is the right news and/or signal from the market for the stock to start bottoming. 

And the analysts are still bullish on the stock as well. Although the sentiment and price target have been waning the community is still rating a Hold/Moderate Buy with a price target that is about 37% above the new lows. The most recent activity, the 6 analysts' commentaries that we’ve tracked since the report was released, include 6 price target reductions and 1 downgrade to Equal Weight that have the stock trading closer to $77 which is still about 15% above the recent price action and suggests a rebound will happen once the market starts to bottom. 

CarMax Falls On Weak Results 

CarMax had an OK quarter if one that was deeply impacted by headwinds within the industry. The company reported $8.14 billion in revenue for a gain of 1.9% over last year but missed the analyst's consensus estimate by 480 basis points. The miss is due in part to rising prices and interest rates and their impact on the consumer. In regard to units, the number of retail units fell 6.4% versus last year with comp store volume falling 8.3% and wholesale by -15%. This was offset by an increase in car price but the increase was far less than the analysts were looking for and not enough to sustain the margin. 

The margin was impacted at the gross and operating levels by a pullback in used-car value and an increase in SG&A. The increase in SG&A is due in part to higher cost and increased labor but also by increased investment in digital and growth. The bad news is that $0.79 in GAAP earnings is $0.58 weaker than expected and below the prepandemic level as well. The takeaway, however, is that while there are headwinds in the near term the company’s revenue is up more than 55% versus the prepandemic level while the stock is trading at a 30% discount. It may take some time but the market for used cars will stabilize as will the market for CarMax stock. 

The Technical Outlook: CarMax Falls To Support 

The price action in CarMax took a dive after the Q2 results were released but the stock may already be at the bottom. Price action was halted above the $63 level and has begun to rebound although it is very early in the move to call a bottom. If the market follows through on this move and advances from here a retest of the support is highly likely in the least. Longer-term, the market for CarMax may establish a trading range at these levels that linger until there is evidence the headwinds are weakening or longer. 

Companies in This Article:

About Thomas Hughes

[email protected]

Experience

Thomas Hughes has been a contributing writer for InsiderTrades.com since 2019.

Areas of Expertise

Technical analysis, the S&P 500; retail, consumer, consumer staples, dividends, high-yield, small caps, technology, economic data, oil, cryptocurrencies

Education

Associate of Arts in Culinary Technology

Past Experience

Market watcher, trader and investor for numerous websites. Founded Passive Market Intelligence LLC to provide market research insights. 

More From MarketBeat

This Crypto Is Set to Explode in December

It's a groundbreaking opportunity that could be poised for extraordinary gains. The catalyst behind this su...

Crypto 101 Media | Sponsored

7 Nuclear Energy Stocks to Buy on Growing Demand

The question isn't if nuclear energy is making a comeback, but why? There are several answers, starting with t...

MarketBeat

Did You See Trump’s Bombshell Exec. Order 001?

Starting with what I call Exec. Order 001. It’s a bombshell law that I believe Trump will sign within minut...

Banyan Hill Publishing | Sponsored

7 of the Best Stocks to Buy with $5,000

If you have $5,000 to put into the market, first take a moment to congratulate yourself. That's no small accom...

MarketBeat

WARNING: “Buffett Indicator” flashing for first time in 50 years

Warren Buffett has sold a staggering $97 billion worth of stocks this year... But why? Our research indi...

Behind the Markets | Sponsored

8 Retail Stocks to Own For the Long Haul

After the 2020 e-commerce boom, everyone thought we had taken a 10-year leap in online shopping. Amazon was op...

MarketBeat

Your bank is lying to you.

You might think you have your money in a high-yield savings account, but do you really? The national average A...

MyBankTracker | Sponsored

7 Stocks with Recent Downgrades Worth a Second Look

Analyst ratings can be a key piece of information that investors look for in stock evaluation. Typically, anal...

MarketBeat